Why Did Naoko Start Writing Sailor Moon Attack Names in Kanji?

Sailor Moon and the Holy Grail

Sailor Moon and the Holy Grail

While I’m well aware that the majority of the audience who reads this blog probably watched/read Sailor Moon in translation, I think it’s sometimes informative to take a look at the more in-depth Japanese linguistics issues that, even though they don’t have a substantial impact on the series as a whole, they still would stand out and affect the interpretation of a native Japanese speaker.

And besides, I live for this geeky Japanese interpretation stuff.

I hope you join along for this trip through the bizarre world of the kanji wordplay! If we’re really lucky, maybe we’ll have even learned something at the end of this!

We're actually not talking about English at all...

We’re actually not talking about English at all…

If you’ve made it this far into reading/watching Sailor Moon and undoubtedly countless other anime, I’m going to assume that you’re probably familiar with the fact that Japanese uses multiple writing systems.1 While hiragana and katakana are phonetic and (usually…) have a one-to-one correspondence between a character and a sound,2 each kanji has a unique meaning and can (generally…) be pronounced multiple ways.

We’ve seen this unique aspect of kanji abused often in the Sailor Soldiers’ names, for example.

But just in case that wasn’t confusing enough, Japanese media often likes to “kick it up a notch” and make up entirely arbitrary readings for kanji, which allows the author to choose an exotic-sounding name while also utilizing the meaning of the kanji to tip the reader off as to what it means.

It’s a lot like having your cake and eating it too, basically.

Did someone say cake??

Did someone say cake??

This use of kanji for its meaning, irrespective of reading, is known as ateji (当て字; lit. “assigned characters”),3 and is very common in manga.4 If you’ve ever seen me get into grumpy-old-man arguments about how manga is an awful way to try to learn Japanese, this is one reason why.

So with that out of the way, let’s get back to the subject at hand!

Read also:  Is Moonlight Densetsu a Rewrite of Another Song?

Though Ms. Takeuchi did do this on occasion throughout the entire run of Sailor Moon, there was a sudden change in the Infinity arc where we suddenly see a lot of attack names get the full-kanji treatment.

Some examples include (note that, for the Outer Senshi, not all are from the Infinity arc):

  • Sailor Moon: Rainbow Moon Heartache (虹色月心激)
  • Sailor Mercury: Mercury Aqua Mirage (水蜃気楼)
  • Sailor Mars: Mars Snake Fire (蛇火炎)
    • Sailor Mars’ cd single for Sailor Stars was titled Flame Sniper (炎の狙撃者), but this one is debatable because you could argue it’s a Japanese translation
  • Sailor Uranus:
    • World Shaking (天界震)
    • Space Sword Blaster (宇宙剣乱風)
    • Space Turbulence (宇宙乱気流)
  • Sailor Neptune:
    • Deep Submerge (深水没)
    • Submarine Reflection (深海鏡射)
    • Submarine Violon Tide (深海提琴潮流)5
  • Sailor Pluto:
    • Dead Scream (破滅喘嗚)
    • Dark Dome Close (冥空封印)
    • Garnet Ball (時空球)
    • Chronos Typhoon (時空嵐撃)
  • Sailor Saturn:
    • Death Reborn Revolution (死世界変革)
    • Silence Wall (不動城壁)
    • Silence Glaive Surprise (沈黙鎌奇襲)
Submarine Violon Tide (深海提琴潮流)

Submarine Violon Tide (深海提琴潮流)

So what gives?

I haven’t been able to find any official explanation for this change, but a 1995 Japanese fan book has an interesting theory on the subject.6

A possible reason for this change was due to Sailor Moon‘s rise in popularity in China. According to the fab¥n book, Chinese translators weren’t always familiar with the tokusatsu/Super Sentai7 style of fighting, which typically involves the characters calling out their attacks. This led to some of the Chinese translations suffering from awkward dialogue, since the Sailor Soldiers’s special attacks were simply translated literally, as if they were normal speech.

This problem is even further compounded when you consider that Ms. Takeuchi and the anime usually used English words for the special attacks. This made it an even bigger burden on the Japanese to Chinese translator, as they needed to be familiar with the English word as well.

So, the story goes, Ms. Takeuchi started using kanji for many of these attack names to give the Chinese translators (and fans!) a clearer understanding of what she intended for this attack to mean. And, in cases where the Chinese and Japanese meanings for given kanji/hanzi compounds are the same, the Chinese translators could use them as-is.

Mercury Aqua Mirage (水蜃気楼)

Mercury Aqua Mirage (水蜃気楼)

This is by no means an “official” answer to the question, but I personally think it explains things pretty well. In fact, if you take a look through lists of Chinese translations for the relevant attacks, they often are the same or come pretty close to the kanji Ms. Takeuchi provided. Even if this isn’t the reason, the end result is certainly the same.

Read also:  How Were Haruka and Michiru's VAs Told to Portray Their Characters?

The biggest hole in this theory, though, is why it’s mostly restricted to the Infinity arc, and why Jupiter and Venus’ attacks are missing. I can come up with plausible reasons why she stopped — namely that many of her readers were young and the insane kanji compounds aren’t young reader-friendly — but it’s still odd.

Personally, I prefer having the attacks written out in kanji, because it gives you a sense of what Ms. Takeuchi was aiming for when she chose the attack names. But what do you think about all this? Just a stylistic choice for the Infinity arc, or was there some sort of deeper plan involved?? It’d be fun to hear other theories!


References:

  1. And in case you aren’t, see Japanese Writing System (Wikipedia)
  2. Except へ, は, and some edge cases with silent “vowels,” but who’s counting?
  3.  See 当て字 (Jisho.org)
  4.  See this Japanese list of ateji in manga
  5. Yes, violon… the French spelling of violin
  6.  See p. 26 of 美少女戦士の研究
  7.  See Tokusatsu (Wikipedia) and Super Sentai (Wikipedia)

2 thoughts on “Why Did Naoko Start Writing Sailor Moon Attack Names in Kanji?

  1. The literal translation of the kanji sometimes adds perspective to the attacks named:

    Rainbow Moon Heartache (虹色月心激) – “Rainbow-coloured heart stimulation of the moon”

    Mercury Aqua Mirage (水蜃気楼) – “Mirage of water and air”

    Mars Snake Fire (蛇火炎) – “Snake fire”

    World Shaking (天界震) – “Quake of the heavenly realm”

    Space Sword Blaster (宇宙剣乱風) – “Chaotic wind of the Universe Sword”

    Space Turbulence (宇宙乱気流) – “Chaotic air turbulence of the universe”

    Deep Submerge (深水没) – “Sinking in deep water”

    Submarine Reflection (深海鏡射) – “Mirror projection in the deep ocean”

    Submarine Violon Tide (深海提琴潮流) – “Tidal flow of the held zither in the deep ocean”; the literal Chinese name for the violin is “small held zither”, as contrasted with ancient East Asian zithers which sit on a table during performance. See the Wikipedia articles for “Guqin” and “Yamatogoto”.

    Dead Scream (破滅喘嗚) – “Destructive scream of suffocation”

    Dark Dome Close (冥空封印) – “Seal of Death’s domain”

    Garnet Ball (時空球) – “Ball of time and space”

    Chronos Typhoon (時空嵐撃) – “Storm strike of time and space”

    Death Reborn Revolution (死世界変革) – “Revolution of the dead world”

    Silence Wall (不動城壁) – “Immovable rampart”

    Silence Glaive Surprise (沈黙鎌奇襲) – “Ambush of the Silent Glaive”

  2. The only other case of a magical attack being written in Chinese characters outside Infinity arc was, if I recall correctly, 桂花百花繚亂 (Kinmoku Fusion Tempest).
    Personally, I would also love to have all of the attacks written like that just for that little bit of additional semantic nuance (and because I mostly abhor katakana words xP).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *